10 of the best Norfolk Island restaurants and cafes

Dine on everything from homegrown produce to fresh-from-the-sea fare, locally churned cheese and more on Norfolk Island.

Slow food is more than a movement on Norfolk Island, it’s a way of life – and visitors reap the benefits.  With ninety-nine per cent of fresh food grown in the island’s rich volcanic soil, a bounty of fresh seafood waiting just offshore and a long list of locally-made meats, cheese, coffee and honey, every meal is a simple but delicious occasion.

Locals have well and truly made the most of what they’ve been given, starting with the bananas; green bananas are fried into crispy fritters or cooked in milk to create ‘mudda’ (dumplings), while overripe bananas are mashed and baked to create pihli or used in a pudding. Nothing is wasted.

There are over 30 restaurants, cafes and takeaway shops to choose from – no small feat for an island roughly eight kilometres long and five kilometres wide. Here, find a foodie hit list for those with a hearty appetite.

1. The Olive Café

The smell of bacon cooking on the grill and freshly brewed Campos Coffee lures just about everyone in town to The Olive Café come dawn.

The cafe is open Thursday to Tuesday from 6.30am to 2pm for breakfast, brunch, lunch, morning and afternoon tea. The menu is cheap, cheerful and written on a blackboard.

Find hearty staples such as breakfast burgers, French toast and fluffy pancakes early in the day, and their signature burgers, salads and sandwiches come lunch. Freshly baked cakes and pastries are also available.

The Olive Cafe is one of the busiest on the island

2. Bailey’s Restaurant

Located at Governor’s Lodge on Norfolk Island, Bailey’s Restaurant is known for its historic atmosphere and modern Australian à la carte menu. The menu offers an array of dishes that highlight the culinary creativity and local flavours of Norfolk Island. Take advantage of the seafood options which include features dishes such as seared scallops, seafood pappardelle, kaffir lime tiger prawns, and garlic prawn hot pot. Sit inside the cosy interior that oozes historic charm, or hop out onto the veranda to embrace the warm weather and surrounding gardens.

The restaurant is housed within Governor’s Lodge. (Image: Rob Nibset)

3. Salty Beer Garden

4. The Homestead Restaurant

It’s the wood-fuelled Argentinian Perilla grill at the Homestead Restaurant that elevates the dining experience. Cooking over embers intensifies the flavours of the island’s seasonal produce, meat and seafood – and it’s all thanks to the owner’s dad, who engineered it for Kurt and Jill Menghetti.

The pair opened the doors to the contemporary boutique restaurant housed inside a 1930s island home in October 2019. They have been pairing simple ingredients with the elemental technique of cooking over embers – with mouth-watering results – ever since. Alongside an extensive a-la-carte menu, The Homestead also bakes Norfolk’s only true wood-fired naturally fermented sourdough. It has its own cult following and remains a staple on the menu.

Kurt and Jill Menghetti opened the Homestead Restaurant in 2019

6. Hilli Restaurant and Cafe

In the unique Norfolk language, ‘hilli’ can be translated to a drowsy, lazy feeling. A feeling that comes when you’ve eaten your fill of delicious food followed by a dulcet food coma. And that is exactly the kind of satisfaction you can expect from a meal at the Hilli Restaurant and Cafe.

Order a serving of scones with jam and cream alongside a steaming hot cup of Devonshire tea to be enjoyed overlooking the gardens. Return for dinner to indulge in that famous Norfolk Island seafood. Don’t miss the salt and pepper calamari or the seafood crepe; featuring succulent prawns, calamari and local trumpeter that is bound in a seasoned Mornay sauce and then rolled into a delicate French crepe.

Hilli Restaurant and Café sits within the pristine Victoria Gardens

7. Bounty Bar and Grill

Housed within a charming 1900s building is Bounty Bar and Grill. The contemporary menu champions local meats and produce with a range of share platters to choose from. A surprising standout is the Surf and Turf: a juicy steak cooked to your liking served alongside crispy prawns.

Bounty Bar and Grill offers a menu full of local meats and produce.

8. Two Chimneys Winery

The Two Chimneys Winery is the place to get a premium drop on the island. Established by Noelene McAlpine and her husband Rod, find eight grape varieties surrounding the picturesque homestead. Grab one of the tasty platters which showcase Noelene’s creativity in the kitchen; her homemade cheese ball goes nicely with local marinated mushrooms, orange and paw paw. A glass of Semillon rounds out the experience.

The Two Chimneys Winery is the place to get a premium drop on the island

9. Baunti Tours

If the above list has already invoked a passion for Norfolk Island produce then Baunti Tours has just the ticket to help you take it to the next level. They offer progressive dinners at private island homes, traditional island food and farm tours for hungry tourists.

The Baunti people have strong links with the Bounty mutineers and their Polynesian partners. Their tours elevate your knowledge of the island’s creation and how its inhabitants have transitioned to contemporary life – all with plenty of eating along the way, of course.

Bounti Tours offers progressive dinners featuring Norfolk history

Discover some of the best accommodation on Norfolk Island.